Posted on 24-11-2009
Filed Under (Liberty, Stupid People, justice) by Zach

Alexa Conradi, head honcho at the Quebec Women’s Federation has called for the preservation of the gun registry.  What’s interesting about this call is that to support it, Conradi chose to invoke the tragedy of the 1989 shootings at École polytechnique.  14 women were killed when an insane madman who’s name should oft not be repeated, took a rifle into the school and murdered them in cold blood.  Families of the victims in this shooting had a key role in creating the gun registry and have publicly decried the possibility of it being dismantled.

I say that the choice to invoke this tragedy is interesting because I don’t see how it’s really connected to the need for a gun registry.  In fact, it’s like fear mongering to push a gun control agenda and using fear and women as pawns to further that aim.  Frankly, it’s not as interesting as it is disgusting.  In her speech, Conradi gave no credible reason to believe that a gun registry would have prevented the 1989 shooting or even mitigated the harm done by the shooter.  Conradi gave no honest indication as to how the gun registry would have prevented the shooter from taking a gun to the school or how the victims would have been protected by a registration number attached to a rifle, assuming that the rifle would have been legally obtained.

Alexa Conradi is either horribly misled to believe that a gun registry is some how effective in disabling the firing mechanism of a rifle or she is using women and fear to drive a gun control agenda.  If the latter is true, she should be ousted from her organization and chastized by women across Canada for abusing her role as head of the Quebec Women’s Federation.  Either that or she can concisely and clearly explain how a gun registry would have protected shooting victims in 1989 and why she chose to invoke that painful memory.

(1) Comment    Read More   

Comments

Jason on 24 November, 2009 at 6:27 pm #

Hey Zach, it’s great to be reading your stuff again. I hope you keep posting.

Your perspective on this issue is refreshing. Like you, I am not a big advocate for the gun registry. That’s not to say I don’t think there shouldn’t be any legislation for gun control. I think people who live in large cities such as Montreal and Toronto see a real need for legislation to regulate the circulation of guns in Canada. Here are a few link you should check out. (I’ve also blogged about it so I added my link as well.)

http://montrealsimon.blogspot.com/2009/11/gun-registry-and-progressive-bloggers.html

http://montrealsimon.blogspot.com/2009/11/appalling-betrayal-of-feminism.html

http://montrealsimon.blogspot.com/2009/11/cons-and-great-rural-urban-divide.html

http://thegaywhitenorth.blogspot.com/2009/11/this-hot-button-needs-to-be-cooled.html

Ultimately, I think the solution is to change the consequences people face if they commit a crime with a hand gun. There is no way gun control will prevent people from obtaining a hand gun or prevent the tragic events of 1989. But if someone faces MORE jail time for using hand guns, the may deter.


Post a Comment
Name:
Email:
Website:
Comments: